When you think of Thanksgiving, you probably picture cozy tables, family gatherings, and a feast full of gratitude. But did you know that even behind the bars of one of the most infamous prisons in the world, Thanksgiving was still celebrated? During a visit to Alcatraz with my family here in San Francisco, I stumbled upon an extraordinary piece of history: actual menus from Thanksgiving meals served at Alcatraz in the 1940s.
This post is your exclusive peek into how inmates dined during the holidays, blending spooky October vibes with a surprising dash of comfort food history. Ready to step into the Alcatraz dining hall? Let’s go!
Dining Hall: The Most Dangerous Room on Alcatraz
The dining hall wasn’t just a place to eat. It was one of the most dangerous spaces on the island. Inmates had access to metal knives, forks, and spoons, which meant guards had to patrol closely. Yet despite the risks, food at Alcatraz was considered some of the best in the U.S. federal prison system.
Why? Because guards and inmates ate the same meals. Quality and variety were a priority, even on a holiday like Thanksgiving.
The Thanksgiving Menu of 1946
During my visit, I discovered two menus from the 1940s:
Menu #1
Starter
Peanut Soup
Buttered Peas
Hot Biscuits
Main
Roast Turley with Celery Dressing
Candied Sweet Potatoes
Giblet Gravy
Cranberry Sauce
Dessert
Fresh Grapes
Pumpkin Pie
Bread, Oleo, Coffee
Menu #2
Starter
Cheese Sticks
Celery Curls
Grapefruit and Avocado Salad
Main
Roast Young Turkey
Giblet Gravy
Oyster Stuffing
Cranberry Jelly
Candied Sweet Potatoes
Dessert
Fresh Pumpkin Pie
Fruits, Nuts, Coffee
Only the first menu (#1) came from Alcatraz itself. The second menu I saw came from an Army and Navy hospital in Arkansas in 1944. Both menus were from the same era, but the Alcatraz version really stood out as an effort to keep spirits up on Thanksgiving Day.
This feast was surprisingly traditional, the kind of spread you’d expect in a family home, not a maximum-security prison. Officials believed that serving hearty, familiar meals helped maintain morale and order among the inmates.
Why It Matters Today
Looking back, it’s striking to realize that even in a place known for isolation and strict discipline, food was seen as a way to bring a touch of humanity. For us today, it’s a reminder that meals, especially Thanksgiving, are more than just food. They’re about connection, comfort, and care.
🍱 Bring Thanksgiving (and Halloween!) to Your Lunchboxes
With Canadian Thanksgiving in October, Halloween’s spooky vibes, and U.S. Thanksgiving in November, this rare glimpse into Alcatraz meals is the perfect story to share (and even inspire your own lunchbox ideas).
On Teuko, you can search for:
- Thanksgiving lunchbox ideas to make holiday flavors kid-friendly
- Halloween lunchbox inspiration for spooky, fun October meals
- Or browse by your kids’ favorite foods with our Teuko Search tool.
And don’t miss our free weekly newsletter packed with seasonal lunchbox ideas, tips, and family-friendly inspiration. 👉 Subscribe here:
Teuko Blog 